Analysis of results for the nine months ended September 30, 2016 versus results for the nine months ended September 30, 2015
Total steel shipments for 9M 2016 decreased 1.5% at 63.9 million metric tonnes as compared with 64.8 million metric tonnes for 9M 2015, primarily due to lower shipments in Brazil -8.7%, NAFTA -2.7% and Europe -1.6% offset by higher shipments in ACIS +8.2%. On a comparable basis (considering the sale of long steel producing subsidiaries in the US (LaPlace and Vinton) in 2Q 2016 and Zaragoza in Spain during 3Q 2016), total steel shipments for 9M 2016 were 1.1% lower as compared with 64.1 million metric tonnes for 9M 2015.
Sales for 9M 2016 decreased by 14.0% to $42.7 billion as compared with $49.6 billion for 9M 2015, primarily due to lower average steel selling prices (-12.4%), lower steel shipments (-1.5%), lower seaborne iron ore reference prices (-7.6%), and lower marketable iron ore shipments (-16.3%).
Depreciation of $2.0 billion for 9M 2016 was lower as compared to $2.4 billion for 9M 2015, primarily on account of foreign exchange impact following the appreciation of the US dollar against major currencies and savings from reduced asset base following impairments recorded at the end of 2015. FY 2016 depreciation is expected to be approximately $2.7 billion (based on current exchange rates) reduced from previous $2.8 billion guidance in 2Q 2016.
Impairment charges for 9M 2016 were $49 million related to the sale of ArcelorMittal Zaragoza in Spain, as compared to impairment charges of $46 million for 9M 2015 primarily related to closure of the Vereeniging meltshop in South Africa ($27 million) and the closure of the Georgetown facility in the US ($19 million).
Exceptional income for 9M 2016 was $832 million relating to a one-time gain on employee benefits following the signing of the new US labour contract. Exceptional charges of $527 million for 9M 2015 included $0.5 billion related to the write-down of inventory following the rapid decline of international steel prices and also included $27 million of retrenchment costs in South Africa.
Operating income for 9M 2016 was $3.4 billion as compared to operating income of $1.2 billion in 9M 2015. Operating results for 9M 2016 were positively impacted by exceptional income as discussed above. Operating results for 9M 2015 were negatively impacted by a $69 million provision primarily related to onerous hot rolled and cold rolled contracts in the US (NAFTA) and exceptional charges discussed above.
Income from investments in associates, joint ventures and other investments in 9M 2016 was higher at $601 million as compared to income in 9M 2015 of $153 million, primarily due to the gain on disposal of stakes in Gestamp[4] ($329 million) and Hunan Valin[5] ($74 million) as well as improved performance of the Calvert joint venture and Chinese investees. Income from investments in associates, joint ventures and other investments in 9M 2015 includes $55 million income generated from the share swap with respect to Gerdau[6].
Net interest expense (including interest expense and interest income) was lower at $893 million in 9M 2016, as compared to $966 million in 9M 2015, driven by savings from early bond repayments in 9M 2016 (see recent developments for details on bonds repaid in 3Q 2016) and repayment at maturity on June 3, 2016 of the €1 billion 9.375% bond. The Company continues to expect full year 2016 net interest expense of approximately $1.1 billion.
Foreign exchange and other net financing costs were $664 million for 9M 2016 as compared to foreign exchange and other net financing costs of $1,238 million for 9M 2015. Foreign exchange gains/losses primarily relate to the impact of the USD movements on Euro denominated deferred tax assets and Euro denominated debt. For the 9M 2016 foreign exchange gain of $124 million was recorded (as compared to a loss of $593 million for 9M 2015), mainly on account of USD depreciation of 2.5% against the Euro (versus 7.7% appreciation in 9M 2015), 20.3% depreciation against BRL (versus 33.1% appreciation in 9M 2015) and 32.6% appreciation against the tenge currency in Kazakhstan[7] in 9M 2015. Foreign exchange and other net financing costs for 9M 2016 also includes $0.4 billion premium incurred on the early redemption of bonds.
ArcelorMittal recorded an income tax expense of $1.0 billion for 9M 2016 as compared to an income tax expense of $461 million for 9M 2015. The tax expense in 9M 2016 includes derecognition of deferred tax assets (DTA) amounting to $0.7 billion in Luxembourg. This derecognition (or impairment) is related to revised expectations of DTA recoverability in US dollar terms, and is not related to a deterioration of expected future taxable income.
Non-controlling interests for 9M 2016 were a charge of $21 million as compared to income of $82 million for 9M 2015. Non-controlling interests for 9M 2016 represents a charge primarily related to minority shareholders’ share of net income recorded in ArcelorMittal Mines Canada and Belgo Bekaert Arames in Brazil partially offset by losses generated by ArcelorMittal South Africa. Non-controlling interests for 9M 2015 include income primarily related to losses generated by ArcelorMittal South Africa.
ArcelorMittal’s net income for 9M 2016 was $1,376 million, or $0.49 earnings per share, as compared to a net loss for 9M 2015 of $1,260 billion, or $0.54 loss per share.
Analysis of results for 3Q 2016 versus 2Q 2016 and 3Q 2015
Total steel shipments for 3Q 2016 were 8.1% lower at 20.3 million metric tonnes as compared with 22.1 million metric tonnes for 2Q 2016 primarily due to a seasonal slowdown in Europe (-13.8%) and declines in NAFTA (-1.4%) and ACIS (-1.3%) offset in part by 2.3% improvement in Brazil.
Steel shipments for 3Q 2016 were 3.6% lower as compared to 21.1 million metric tonnes for 3Q 2015. On a comparable basis (considering the sale of long steel producing subsidiaries in the US (LaPlace and Vinton) in 2Q 2016 and Zaragoza in Spain during 3Q 2016), total steel shipments for 3Q 2016 were 3.0% lower as compared with 20.8 million metric tonnes for 3Q 2015.
Sales for 3Q 2016 were $14.5 billion as compared to $14.7 billion for 2Q 2016 and $15.6 billion for 3Q 2015. Sales in 3Q 2016 were 1.5% lower as compared to 2Q 2016, primarily due to seasonally lower steel shipments (-8.1%), lower market-priced iron ore shipments (-15.5%), offset in part by higher average steel selling prices (+7.4%) and higher iron ore reference prices (+5.3%). Sales in 3Q 2016 were 6.8% lower as compared to 3Q 2015 primarily due to lower steel shipment volumes (-3.6%), lower average steel selling prices (-2.0%), lower market-priced iron ore shipments (-21.4%), offset in part by higher iron ore reference prices (+6.7%).
Depreciation was $693 million for 3Q 2016 as compared to $680 million in 2Q 2016. Depreciation was lower in 3Q 2016 as compared to $777 million for 3Q 2015 primarily due to decreased asset base following impairments recorded at the end of 2015 and foreign exchange impacts.
Impairment charges for 3Q 2016 were nil. Impairment charges for 2Q 2016 were $49 million related to the sale of ArcelorMittal Zaragoza facility in Spain. Impairment charges for 3Q 2015 were $27 million relating to the closure of the Vereeniging meltshop in South Africa.
Exceptional items for 3Q 2016 were nil. Exceptional income for 2Q 2016 was $832 million relating to a one-time gain on employee benefits following the signing of the new US labour contract. Exceptional charges for 3Q 2015 were $527 million, including $0.5 billion related to the write-down of inventory following the rapid decline of international steel prices and also included $27 million of retrenchment costs in South Africa.
Operating income for 3Q 2016 was $1.2 billion as compared to $1.9 billion in 2Q 2016 and $20 million in 3Q 2015. Operating results for 2Q 2016 and 3Q 2015 were impacted by exceptional income and charges as discussed above.
Income from investments in associates, joint ventures and other investments for 3Q 2016 was lower at $109 million as compared to $168 million for 2Q 2016 primarily due to weaker performance of the Calvert joint venture, Spanish and Chinese investees offset in part by the gain on disposal of ArcelorMittal’s stake in Hunan Valin ($74 million). Income from investments in associates, joint ventures and other investments for 2Q 2016 included an annual dividend received from Erdemir ($44 million). Income from investments in associates, joint ventures and other investments in 3Q 2015 was $30 million primarily due to weaker performance from Chinese investees offset in part by income generated from the share swap in Gerdau.
Net interest expense in 3Q 2016 was $255 million as compared to $306 million in 2Q 2016 and $318 million in 3Q 2015. Net interest expense was lower in 3Q 2016 as compared to 2Q 2016 and 3Q 2015 primarily due to savings from early bond repayments via debt tenders in 2Q 2016, early redemption of a bond in 2Q 2016 and repayment at maturity on June 3, 2016, of a €1 billion 9.375% bond.
Foreign exchange and other net financing costs in 3Q 2016 was $223 million as compared to foreign exchange and other net financing costs of $450 million for 2Q 2016 and foreign exchange and other net financing costs of $409 million for 3Q 2015. Foreign exchange gains/losses primarily relate to the impact of the USD movements on Euro denominated deferred tax assets and Euro denominated debt. For 3Q 2016 a foreign exchange gain of $65 million was recorded (as compared to a loss of $47 million for 2Q 2016) mainly as a result of a 0.5% depreciation of the USD against the Euro (versus 2.5% appreciation in 2Q 2016) and a 1.1% appreciation against BRL (versus 10.9% depreciation in 2Q 2016). Foreign exchange and other net financing costs for 3Q 2016 also include $158 million premiums incurred on the bond repayments via debt tenders as compared to $237 million premiums incurred on the bond repayments via debt tenders and early redemption of a bond during 2Q 2016. Foreign exchange and other net financing costs for 3Q 2015 include a foreign exchange loss of $170 million mainly on account of 21.9% appreciation of the USD against BRL and stable USD/Euro relative to the prior period.
ArcelorMittal recorded an income tax expense of $146 million for 3Q 2016 as compared $153 million for 2Q 2016 and $127 million for 3Q 2015.
Non-controlling interests for 3Q 2016 of $9 million represent a charge primarily related to minority shareholders’ share of net income recorded in ArcelorMittal Mines Canada and Belgo Bekaert Arames in Brazil partially offset by losses generated by ArcelorMittal South Africa. Non-controlling interests for 2Q 2016 of $20 million represent a charge primarily related to minority shareholders’ share of net income recorded in ArcelorMittal Mines Canada and Belgo Bekaert Arames in Brazil. Non-controlling interests for 3Q 2015 amounted to an income of $93 million primarily related to losses generated by ArcelorMittal South Africa partially offset by share of net income recorded in ArcelorMittal Mines Canada and Belgo Bekaert Arames in Brazil.
ArcelorMittal recorded net income for 3Q 2016 of $680 million, or $0.22 earnings per share as compared to net income for 2Q 2016 of $1,112 million, or $0.38 earnings per share, and as compared to net loss of $711 million, or $0.31 loss per share for 3Q 2015.
Capital expenditure projects
The following tables summarize the Company’s principal growth and optimization projects involving significant capital expenditures.